More Michiganders weighing the costs for long-term care
Thursday, January 3rd, 2008Long Tern Care!!! If you haven’t heard of it get ready, it is the hottest topic in the insurance industry. As Baby Boomers move toward their senior years this subject is getting more attention. The reason? Well, there isn’t one clear answer. However, concerns include Baby Boomers who have, or currently are, caring for elderly parents and don’t want that responsibility to fall to their children. Another reason is the increasing costs of quality care, and an average life expectancy that grows each year.
All of these factors, and more, have people looking toward Long Term Care and exploring their options for their December years.
The following article published in the January 1, 2008 Detroit Free Press gives an overview of the Long Term Care arena and some concerns that are associated with this insurance coverage. For more questions on Long Term Care please contact me through this website–Marty O’Neill, Insurance Agent
January 1, 2008
BY RUBY L. BAILEY
FREE PRESS STAFF WRITER
Teresa Alexander can usually spot a good deal. She’s snagged cars at cost, computers on clearance and her suburban home at an auction for an estimated 40% less than what it was worth. But after months of research resulting in stacks of information from four insurance companies, Alexander still can’t figure out whether long-term care insurance is a good deal for her. The pile of envelopes covered with six months of dust attests to her inability to decide.
“Every time I reach for that pile, I get a headache,” said Alexander, 51, who’s using her maiden name and won’t reveal the city she lives in for fear of receiving more calls and letters from insurance agents. “There’s too many ways to go wrong and end up either paying for something I won’t use or drop it and not have my care covered when I need the help.”
A growing number of consumers like Alexander of southeast Oakland County are considering long-term care insurance. Experts anticipate Michigan’s large population of people 60 and older will add to the nation’s 8 million policyholders as they seek ways to pay for long-term care. Seniors, who now make up 12% of the state’s population, will comprise 15% by 2020 and 19% by 2030, according to estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau.
In Michigan, roughly 137,000 residents had long-term care insurance policies in 2005, up from 127,000 in 2004, according to the state’s office of long-term care. Long-term care insurance pays for what health care plans typically don’t — stays in nursing homes and assisted-living facilities or in-home assistance.
Experts estimate that nearly half of those 65 and older will spend some time in a nursing home or need long-term care. And not everyone will meet Medicaid’s stringent income requirements to qualify for nursing home benefits. Medicaid, run jointly by the state and federal governments, will pay for nursing home care after most of a person’s assets have been depleted.
Bankrolling long-term care out of pocket can be costly. A stay in a private nursing home averages $5,340 a month in Michigan, while assisted-living facilities cost $2,430 a month, according to the state Medicare/Medicaid Assistance Program. A home health aide costs an average of $21 per hour.
Depending on the policy features chosen, long-term care insurance could cover any of those forms of care, saving thousands of dollars.
Dropping policies
But here’s the catch that has tripped up Alexander and others: The policies can be expensive, and a person may never use the benefits after paying for them for years. The average policy costs $1,800 to $2,500 a year, and many increase every three to five years. Policies with inflation riders are available but add at least 30% to the cost, insurance agents and experts said. Features vary — including what type of care is covered, when coverage starts and the daily payout amount for care. In 2001, the Government Accountability Office found 60% or more of long-term care policyholders allow their policies to lapse within 10 years of purchase.
“You essentially paid in thousands of dollars, and you essentially got nothing out of it,” said Gail Jensen, a Wayne State University economist and gerontologist whose 2004 study of 1,375 seniors with long-term care insurance found that 204 let their policies lapse after two years. “It’s not just a one-shot deal. You’re committing for the rest of your life. Once you drop the policy, you lose the coverage.”
Jensen said her study showed people dropped the policies because they could not keep up with the payments. And there’s a chance that the insurer may not pay when the benefits are needed. The U.S. House Energy and Commerce Committee is investigating accusations that insurers Conseco and Penn Treaty erroneously denied legitimate claims while collecting billions in premiums. Industry-wide, insurers took in $9.5 billion in premiums in 2006, up from $8.25 billion in 2004, according to the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance, the industry’s trade organization. In 2006, the industry paid $3.3 billion in claims, according to the association.
And because more people are purchasing the policies at younger ages, the long-term financial commitment is growing. In 2007, the average age of a policy buyer was 58, down from 67 in 2000, according to the association. Some experts recommend purchasing the policy at a younger age, when rates are likely to be lower and consumers are less likely to be turned down because of illness. One in five applicants is denied because of health issues, insurance agents and consumer experts said. But it also means more years of premiums and the increases that could make the policy financially burdensome.
Investing as a strategy
Bob Hull is waiting to find out whether his premiums will increase next year. His insurance plan, which he bought five years ago, allows for premium adjustments every five years.
“I’m anxiously awaiting that decision,” said Hull, who lives in Farmington Hills and didn’t want to give his age. Hull pays more than $1,500 yearly for his policy. “Depending on what they raise it to, I’ll have a little heartburn.”
If the premium doubles, as he fears it might, “I’ll drop it,” said Hull, who chose his plan after comparing five companies. His policy includes options for assisted living, in-home care and nursing home care. “To heck with it. I’ll fund it myself.” Self-funding is a route WSU’s Jensen says could work for some.
“I would take the money that I would be paying as a premium and I would invest it in a no-load mutual fund,” Jensen said. “I think the advantage of doing that is that you can accumulate a significant nest egg there. It can go a long way in helping to pay those long-term care expenses.”
Robert Hawyer, 67, said he considered long-term care insurance for himself and his wife, Marilyn, about 10 years ago. But he couldn’t afford the $2,500 yearly premiums.
“I knew it would start there and go up,” Hawyer of Trenton said. In 2002, his wife was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. Long-term care insurance may have helped pay for someone to assist her at home, but Hawyer wonders whether the company would have refused to pay or whether he would have dropped the policy before his wife’s diagnosis. “With that insurance, there are so many ifs,” Hawyer said. “My advice: Put some money aside either way. No matter what, they always take cash.”
Being prepared
But insurance agent Tom Varner of Long-term Care Financial Partners in Metamora said many people may not be disciplined enough to sock away thousands now to pay for care later. “There’s so many misconceptions, and there’s denial and procrastination,” said Varner, who likens long-term care insurance with car, life and homeowners plans. “You’re insuring a huge risk down the road. It may or may not happen to you. That’s always the fly in the ointment.”
That was Joe Kent’s thinking when he bought a long-term care insurance policy three years ago at age 46.
“You have to consider, ‘Gee, I could be on this Earth for another 30-40 years and not be in a position to earn a living,’ ” said Kent, who lives in Addison Township. He pays more than $1,000 yearly for his policy. “Health insurance isn’t going to pay for long-term care. So what is? Your own assets. If you own stuff, you can kiss it good-bye.”
Alexander has wavered between a save-all-the-money-she-can plan and a double-pronged approach of setting aside savings and supplementing it with a bare-bones long-term care insurance policy to keep premiums low and, she hopes, affordable for the next several years.
“The alternatives just stink,” said Alexander, whose New Year’s resolution is to make a decision about a policy. “And either way, you’re betting your future.”